Best Prix Fixe Thanksgiving Restaurants Near NYC

Editor’s Note: This has been updated to reflect 2018 offerings

Thanksgiving is supposed to be a holiday, right? So what’s with all the time spent in the kitchen?  For those of you who would rather sleep in and have the feast prepared for you, here are six restaurants for Thanksgiving dinner done right, each one just a train, bus or boat ride away.

Best Prix Fixe Thanksgiving Restaurants in The Hudson Valley

Rhinecliff Hotel | 4 Grinnell Street, Rhinecliff | 845.876.0590

Ninety minutes north of midtown, this historic railway hotel boasts a scenic perch on the banks of the Hudson—and a two-minute walk from the Amtrak station. Warm up with mulled wine and favorites like their local apple-squash soup, before digging into locally-grown roast turkey topped with cranberry relish. For sides, try the Parsley Glazed Carrots or Brussels Sprouts with Bacon. If it’s up to you, have a Hudson River sunset with your dessert.
Cost: Four-course, $42.95 for adults / $19.95 for children
Times: Seatings offered at 12.00pm, 2.30pm & 5.30pm
Getting There: Amtrak to Rhinecliff Station

Castle on the Hudson | 400 Benedict Avenue, Tarrytown | 914.631.1980

You only have to go 25 miles north of NYC for dinner in a genuine Norman-style castle. Built by a retired civil war general 100 years ago, the castle now operates as a hotel. T-Day dinner at on-site restaurant Equus offers refined options like Butternut Squash Soup, Asian Pear Salad, and Country Ham in a Pineapple Glaze.
Cost
: $105 per adult, $55 children’s menu. The dinner is served family style with buffet of pies for dessert.
Times: Seatings from 12pm to 5:30 pm
Getting There: Metro-North to Tarrytown. Bring a bike—the castle is one mile from the station.

Best Prix Fixe Thanksgiving Restaurants in New Jersey 

Amanda’s | 908 Washington St. | Hoboken, NJ | 201.798.0101

A few blocks from the harbor front in New Jersey, directly across the Hudson from Manhattan, Amanda’s offers one of the area’s most delicious food. Start with the butternut squash soup with bacon and fried kale or honey almond roasted crostini, then ease into a pan seared bass or traditional oven roasted turkey with stuffing before really giving thanks for the apple strudel with fresh whipped cream. No extra charge for sweeping views of the NYC skyline.
Cost: $55 for a three-course meal, kids under 12 half-price
Times:
1:00pm – 7:00pm
Getting there: Take the PATH train or the ferry to Hoboken Terminal.

The Frenchtown Inn |  7 Bridge St. | Frenchtown, NJ | 908.996.3300

Hop on a bus at Port Authority and be whisked away to the quaint town of Frenchtown New Jersey. There settle into a three-course meal at the beautiful Frenchtown Inn. Though their 2018 menu has not yet been released, rest assured that the restaurant’s award winning food and hand crafted cocktails will leave you more than satisfied.  We recommend staying the weekend and exploring Frenchtown: The Best Kept Secret Weekend Destination.
Cost: $68 (adults) and an ala carte children’s menu, not including tax and tip
Times: 12:00 pm – 5:00 pm
Getting there:  Head to Port Authority to take the Transbridge Bus directly to Frenchtown in about two hours. $47.50 round trip.

Best Prix Fixe Thanksgiving Restaurants in New York City

The Farm on Adderley | 1108 Cortelyou Road | 718.287.3101

On November 22, South Brooklyn’s foremost farm-to-table spot will be serving up a traditional (or not so traditional) Thanksgiving feast. Take the classic route with a turkey dinner followed by pie or try a venison mince pie or roasted chanterelles.
Cost: $65 for three-courses. $25 for the children’s menu.
Times: 12:00-8:30PM. Reservations can be made by emailing farmreservations@gmail.com
Getting There: B or Q train to Cortelyou Road

Russo’s on the Bay | 164-45 Cross Bay Blvd. | 718.843.5055

This far-flung Queens neighborhood is best known to most Manhattanites for its proximity to JFK, but it’s also one of the city’s best unheralded stops for opulent Italian-American cuisine. At this waterfront restaurant, start with an antipasto platter of shrimp-stuffed mushrooms, fried calamari and hand-rolled mozzarella with sopressata, before moving on to pork osso bucco or pollo marsala. There’s traditional turkey, too, but of course it comes filled with spicy, sausage stuffing.
Cost: $55 / adult for a four-course meal. Children’s menu for $25
Times: Reservations between 1pm to 6pm
Getting There
: Q41 bus to 164th Avenue/92nd Street

Related posts